D

dagmanVoice #1

Member since July 2026

78 threads34 πŸ‘ received12 replies drawn
Entertainment

Your all-time favorite movie is a... (drop the title in the comments)

Maybe Sound of Music. So depends on my mood.

Sep 18πŸ‘ 0πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
Replying to Dense1: β€œAkira Kurosawa's "Dreams"”

Had to look that one up. Will check it out. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=laMbgNh3uns

Sep 20πŸ‘ 0πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
Tech & Science

Should the government require safety limits on AI chatbots used by minors?

Yes, as with social media. No easy ask, but guardrails are needed, especially as AI capabilities grow. We're in uncharted territory on so many levels.

Sep 19πŸ‘ 0πŸ‘Ž 1Open thread β†’
Replying to Scaramouche: β€œBetter idea: Just tear them all down. They shouldn't exist.”

Genie's out of the bottle now. We need to deal with it before it deals with us.

Sep 20πŸ‘ 0πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
Business & Money

After the Fed raised rates, is President Trump right to demand U.S. interest rates be cut to 1% or lower?

There are very good reasons for an independent Fed. Its mandate is clear: price stability and maximum employment. Interest rate decisions should follow the data, not the will of the president. History shows that politicizing monetary policy leads to bad outcomes. Hands off, POTUS.

Sep 18πŸ‘ 1πŸ‘Ž 13 repliesOpen thread β†’
Replying to Scaramouche: β€œAre you familiar with "The Creature from Jekyll Island"? History shows that flipping democracy the bird doesn't prevent politicization (look…”

Had to look up the Jekyll Island reference :) ... The Fed isn’t above government. It operates under a mandate from Congress. Independence is about who makes day-to-day rate decisions. Making the Fed more responsive to presidential pressure seems more likely to politicize it, not less.

Sep 20πŸ‘ 0πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
Tech & Science

Are you comfortable leaving your physical wallet at home and paying only with your phone?

In case my battery dies...

Sep 19πŸ‘ 0πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
Business & Money

Who is most responsible for high inflation in the U.S. right now?

War + tariffs. 45 days til midterms!

Sep 19πŸ‘ 0πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
News & Politics

What should Trump’s proposed β€œAI Force” prioritize?

Fine line to walk here. We don't want to slow progress or risk getting surpassed by the Chinese. We also need some guardrails to ensure AI doesn't get away from us. The composition of this "AI Force" will be key. Too far in either direction and we're in trouble.

Sep 19πŸ‘ 0πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
Tech & Science

Should the U.S. restrict free Chinese AI models that can boost people's hacking skills?

I'm not sure there's a good way to stop hackers from accessing them. Hackers hack. They'll find a way around any restrictions.

Sep 19πŸ‘ 0πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
News & Politics

Should the U.S. government cancel Americans' medical debt?

Cancelling debt -- whether health, education, or otherwise -- sets a dangerous precedent. We're responsible for our debts. Do, though, address the reasons people get into medical debt in the first place.

Sep 19πŸ‘ 0πŸ‘Ž 11 replyOpen thread β†’
News & Politics

Was President Trump right to extend 'most favored nation' drug pricing to every state's Medicaid program?

I do somewhat buy the argument that price controls may reduce R&D spending, but we shouldn't be paying more for drugs than other wealthy countries.

Sep 19πŸ‘ 1πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
Business & Money

Was the Federal Reserve right to raise interest rates?

Replying to JE_Thomas: β€œThis is a fraught time economically. The last thing we need is growing inflation. Had the Fed held - or worse decreased a quarter - the si…”

Glad to see that Warsh is not a lap dog. There's hope.

Sep 19πŸ‘ 1πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
News & Politics

Is President Trump right to threaten Europe with tariffs over Canada's bid to become an EU 'associate member'?

Newton's third law of motion: Whenever one object exerts a force on a second, the second exerts a force of equal magnitude and opposite direction on the first

Sep 18πŸ‘ 1πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
Replying to JE_Thomas: β€œWhat deal? Trump has taunted Canada about becoming the 51st state, insulted its prime minister, denigrated its people, and levied confiscat…”

Broad-based tariffs seem so last century. I do hope this is the last gasp of last-century trade policy and we can all move on.

Sep 19πŸ‘ 1πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
News & Politics

Was the U.S. right to hold secret talks with Yemen's Houthis rather than join Saudi Arabia's airstrikes?

Replying to JE_Thomas: β€œJaw-jaw is better than war-war - attributed to Winston Churchill The question in my mind is if we have anyone left capable of having meanin…”

If secret talks can protect shipping and keep us out of another war, thumbs up to that. I'm not sure this administration can pull that off, but worth a shot.

Sep 19πŸ‘ 1πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
News & Politics

The House passed a bill to keep AI data centers from raising your electricity bill, but states can still opt out β€” is that enough to protect households?

Federal guardrails, state discretion. That feels like the right balance. And costs should follow demand. Data centers should pay for the grid upgrades they need.

Sep 18πŸ‘ 0πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
Replying to JE_Thomas: β€œIf a state has a surplus of energy there is no reason why it shouldn't host data centers. Further, state governments are much closer to the…”

Agreed. Leave it to the states. Lots to balance here, including jobs growth. Better to lean into the growth trends rather than swim upstream (apologies for the mixed metaphors).

Sep 19πŸ‘ 1πŸ‘Ž 1Open thread β†’
Entertainment

Can a movie remake ever be better than the original?

I don't know. Maybe Ocean's Eleven?

Sep 19πŸ‘ 1πŸ‘Ž 01 replyOpen thread β†’
News & Politics

Should the U.S. face an independent investigation into possible war crimes in Iran?

Err on the side of transparency. Let the facts guide the judgement.

Sep 19πŸ‘ 1πŸ‘Ž 01 replyOpen thread β†’
News & Politics

Was President Trump right to ban CNN, MS NOW, and Politico from the White House?

Of course not. It's the people's house. Mainstream media is our access, and a check on power.

Sep 19πŸ‘ 0πŸ‘Ž 11 replyOpen thread β†’
Business & Money

Is buying cryptocurrency investing or gambling?

Extremely risky investing. Unless it's a stablecoin, in which case it's just very risky.

Sep 18πŸ‘ 1πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
Tech & Science

Would you support building a new nuclear power plant near your community to help power AI data centers?

Replying to Ralph: β€œI would support building new nuclear power plants with any intended use case, really. They probably wouldn't be helpful for the current data…”

Hoping the small modular reactors can shorten this by a lot. If we can't find some flexible new power sources, we're going to feel it in our electric bills.

Sep 18πŸ‘ 0πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
News & Politics

Should Washington, D.C. become the 51st U.S. state?

Replying to missingsample: β€œI used to be opposed on the basis of tradition and that it would be perceived as a partisan powergrab, but after seeing how badly congress h…”

Fair point, but I"m not sure statehood would protect them from the mistreatment. At least under this administration.

Sep 18πŸ‘ 0πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
Entertainment

Will you watch 'Toy Story 5' when it hits Disney+ later this month?

Saw it in theaters but will also stream it. Hoping it will be better the second time.

Sep 18πŸ‘ 0πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
Tech & Science

After OpenAI revealed its own AI models hid mistakes and deceived overseers, do you trust AI companies to keep their products safe on their own?

They need some oversight, for sure. My worry is the models get so good that even those overseeing them, companies or government, won't know they're being deceived.

Sep 18πŸ‘ 1πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
Business & Money

With home heating bills set to jump about 30% this winter, will you keep your thermostat lower to save money?

More sweaters and fireplace fires. After the recent heat wave, I say bring it on.

Sep 18πŸ‘ 0πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
News & Politics

With Canada becoming the European Union's first 'associate member,' is the U.S. driving its closest allies away?

Of course it is. Let's just hope we can mend these relationship when Trump is gone. Unfortunately, trust doesn't reset at inauguration day.

Sep 18πŸ‘ 1πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
Tech & Science

Should the U.S. government take ownership stakes in AI companies like OpenAI?

Hard no. Government’s role is referee, not shareholder.

Sep 18πŸ‘ 1πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
Business & Money

Should the U.S. release oil from its emergency reserve to lower gas prices?

Like the Fed, the oil reserve shouldn't be used as a political tool.

Sep 18πŸ‘ 0πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
News & Politics

Should the FBI send federal agents to U.S. polling places on Election Day?

Replying to JE_Thomas: β€œNo. To what end would they be sent? Study after study including from the Hoover Institution consistently show that voter fraud is rare. T…”

Especially when the agents are not likely to be neutral in motive. Feels very un-American. Trump excels at bringing out the worst in society.

Sep 18πŸ‘ 0πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
News & Politics

Is President Trump helping or hurting Republicans' chances in the 2026 midterm elections?

Replying to David_Reiley: β€œHis policies are very unpopular. War in Iran is raising prices. ICE continues to exhibit lawless cruelty. And he’s spending most of his t…”

48 days and counting!

Sep 17πŸ‘ 0πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
Replying to JE_Thomas: β€œTrump 47 is arguably the worst presidency since Andrew Johnson. He has destroyed America's alliances, destroyed an economic order that has …”

Agree 100%. Reagan and Romney Republicans seem a dying breed. The party is now far more about loyalty to Trump than conservative principles. They've lost their way.

Sep 18πŸ‘ 1πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
Entertainment

Should the Emmy Awards move off broadcast TV to stream on Amazon Prime Video?

How about both?

Sep 18πŸ‘ 0πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
News & Politics

Should the U.S. Mint put President Trump's face on a commemorative coin?

Let's reserve that right for dead presidents, once everyone has had time to reflect on the true impact of the person and there are no repercussions for those deciding. I'm fairly confident Trump would not clear the bar.

Sep 18πŸ‘ 0πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
Just for Fun

How many holes does a drinking straw have?

How many holes in a doughnut? Think of a straw as a long doughnut. Not that it matters.

Sep 17πŸ‘ 0πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
Tech & Science

Should self-driving cars be allowed on public roads with no human backup driver?

90% fewer injuries and crashes with self driving cars. Yes, they should be allowed.

Sep 17πŸ‘ 0πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
Entertainment

Would you watch a movie with an entirely AI-generated cast instead of human actors?

Characters are characters, and stories are stories, but I do think there will still be a premium on knowing that it's real people you're watching. At least for some.

Sep 17πŸ‘ 0πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
News & Politics

Should Canada become an 'associate member' of the European Union?

Hopefully the implications of alienating our closest allies is starting to get more real for Trump (if only that were true)

Sep 17πŸ‘ 1πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
Tech & Science

Was Microsoft right to place limits on how far it develops its most advanced AI models?

They (and maybe Meta) have the least to lose if the pace of progress is constrained.

Sep 15πŸ‘ 1πŸ‘Ž 02 repliesOpen thread β†’
Replying to JE_Thomas: β€œAnd the least to gain if it isn't. I think MS is playing this intelligently and appropriately conservatively. META in my humble analysis i…”

Agree re: Zuckerberg. Not strong on innovation (e.g., $80B+ down the drain on metaverse), though they have made some good acquisitions.

Sep 17πŸ‘ 0πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
News & Politics

Should Mitch McConnell serve out the rest of his U.S. Senate term?

Replying to David_Reiley: β€œI think his constituents deserve to have a functioning Senator. I also think Dianne Feinstein should have resigned when she became too frai…”

I'm okay with physically frail if they're mentally capable. There's something to be said for the wisdom of years (ideally in collaboration with the energy and fresh thinking of youth)

Sep 17πŸ‘ 0πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
Just for Fun

Do you believe in ghosts?

I tend to anchor on what can be proven scientifically. Ghosts haven't met that bar.

Sep 14πŸ‘ 0πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
Replying to rovr322: β€œScience assumes that our human senses are adequate for detecting all that there is to detect in the universe around us, an entirely unprovab…”

Absence of evidence doesn't necessarily mean evidence of absence. I'm okay with that, but if I were a betting man...

Sep 16πŸ‘ 1πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
Replying to rovr322: β€œYep, but when it comes to the afterlife, ultimately we’re all betting men”

True. But I tend to think reality is what it is, regardless of what I believe.

Sep 17πŸ‘ 1πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
Just for Fun

When you get home from a trip, do you unpack right away or live out of the suitcase?

I can't fully relax until all the clothes are in the laundry.

Sep 17πŸ‘ 0πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
Tech & Science

Is OpenAI worth $1.5 trillion?

It's a two horse race right now on the most impactful innovation in human history. I think it's justified, but the risk is huge.

Sep 16πŸ‘ 0πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
News & Politics

Was it right to vote to close Washington's Kennedy Center for the Performing Arts?

As long as Trump is connected to it, it's going to be politicized and suffer from poor ticket sales and performer defections. Renovating it would be great if it weren't dependent on his name being attached. No good answer here except for him to walk away, which I don't see happening.

Sep 16πŸ‘ 1πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
Sports

Should college athletes be treated as paid employees of their schools?

They should be able to share in the value they're creating for the schools (NIL) for sure, but not as employees. They're also there for an education, no?

Sep 16πŸ‘ 0πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
Just for Fun

If you could afford a private jet, would you get one?

I'd like to think I wouldn't, but I might.

Sep 16πŸ‘ 1πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
Tech & Science

Would you let an AI service negotiate your bills and subscriptions for you?

If it saved me money and left all final approvals to me, sure. I wouldn't have said that a year ago, but it's come so far so fast.

Sep 16πŸ‘ 0πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
Tech & Science

Will humans make contact with intelligent alien life in your lifetime?

Not in my lifetime, but at some point. Hard to imagine that we're the only intelligent life.

Sep 13πŸ‘ 1πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
Replying to Scaramouche: β€œWell-said - BUT, I've heard it better-said: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=buqtdpuZxvk”

:) Do miss them. RIP Graham and Terry.

Sep 15πŸ‘ 0πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
Replying to Scaramouche: β€œAbsolutely - but to be clear, you do realize THAT blonde guy was Eric, right?”

Long live Eric!

Sep 16πŸ‘ 1πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
News & Politics

Should the U.S. require companies to slow development of the most advanced AI systems while safety measures catch up?

Whoever gets to recursive self-improving AI first will be at a distinct, and likely permanent, advantage. Slowing the pace is ideal, but the big challenge is ensuring everyone complies. We have to try, but I'm not optimistic.

Sep 14πŸ‘ 0πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’

Trump calls these safety risks a hoax, while leaders of all the AI frontier companies are emphatically warning of the serious consequences and need for action. Who do you believe?

Sep 14πŸ‘ 1πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
Replying to JE_Thomas: β€œI have opinions on many things, but I lack the information to form an informed opinion on this. I use Claude daily and find it powerful and…”

Agreed. I don't feel like there's a clear answer here. We can't let authoritarian countries get ahead, but we can't let ourselves advance beyond our ability to control it. All considered, though, I think the risk of the former outweighs the risk of the latter.

Sep 16πŸ‘ 1πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
Replying to anonymous: β€œI think if the American companies slow down Chinese companies will make less progress. This is because their progress depends on distillatio…”

While that may be true today, I'm not sure that'll be true tomorrow. My fear is that underrates their capabilities.

Sep 16πŸ‘ 1πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
News & Politics

Should the U.S. abolish the Electoral College and elect the president by national popular vote?

Would certainly bring more balance to the process. Candidates already mostly ignore states that aren’t competitive. Let them campaign for each and every vote.

Sep 13πŸ‘ 0πŸ‘Ž 03 repliesOpen thread β†’
Replying to sjs: β€œThis can be done without throwing out the baby, Nebraska and Maine appoint electors by district.”

What's the baby we're throwing out here? Why not an all-in popular vote?

Sep 16πŸ‘ 0πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
News & Politics

Was the U.S. Supreme Court right to block President Trump's mail-in voting restrictions for the 2026 midterms?

Replying to David_Reiley: β€œThe power to run elections resides with the states. Congress has some ability to regulate the state rules, but the President does not. Cha…”

Happy that SCOTUS agrees on this one.

Sep 16πŸ‘ 2πŸ‘Ž 0Best receivedOpen thread β†’
News & Politics

Should students be required to be vaccinated against measles to attend public school?

Replying to JE_Thomas: β€œThis shouldn't even be a question. Vaccination is arguably the most important medical miracle in all of history. It has saved more lives t…”

Especially when those sounding the false alarms are leading the institutions responsible for protecting public health. We really need to course correct. Let's get back to anchoring on the science.

Sep 16πŸ‘ 1πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
News & Politics

Should there be a maximum age limit for U.S. presidents?

Replying to Scaramouche: β€œAge is not the problem; health is. Not everyone ages equally. Bernie Sanders is way the hell older than John Fetterman, but guess whose brai…”

Completely agree. As long as you're capable, you should have a shot.

Sep 15πŸ‘ 0πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
News & Politics

Should the U.S. act as the Middle East's 'regional policeman'?

Replying to Dense1: β€œThe US has a mixed record on this ranging from Eisenhower's response to the Suez Crisis to whatever it is that Trump thinks he's doing in Ir…”

Agree the record's mixed. Success seems to depend on having narrow, well-defined objectives and strong allied support. Trump has been missing the mark on both, unfortunately.

Sep 13πŸ‘ 0πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
Replying to Scaramouche: β€œI'm sure we'll be greeted as liberators just as soon as they hear THE AWESOME THEME-SONG!: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QwI0MpqADzE”

Love that. I'm sure Hegseth would approve.

Sep 15πŸ‘ 0πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
Entertainment

Did the 'Toy Story' movies need a fifth film?

Not one of their best, but it was good to see the gang back.

Sep 15πŸ‘ 0πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
Business & Money

Would a Federal Reserve interest-rate cut this week be good or bad for the U.S. economy?

Well, a cut's off the table, so moot, I think.

Sep 15πŸ‘ 0πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
News & Politics

Should members of Congress keep getting paid during a government shutdown?

No work no pay.

Sep 15πŸ‘ 0πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
Tech & Science

Would you support a new data center in your community?

If there were assurances it wouldn't drive our electric bill up, sure. Otherwise, probably not.

Sep 15πŸ‘ 0πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
News & Politics

Does Donald Trump Jr.’s wedding celebration financed by a Russian businessman with ties to Putin raise legitimate concerns?

For sure. Even the appearance of such influence should be avoided. It speaks further to the family's troubling comfort with turning political access into personal gain.

Sep 15πŸ‘ 0πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
Just for Fun

It's mid-September β€” is it too early for pumpkin spice everything?

Pumpkin spice? Fine. A whole Christmas isle at Costco? Feels a bit early.

Sep 15πŸ‘ 1πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
Business & Money

As U.S. stock markets slide over AI fears, will you change how you invest your savings?

Steady as she goes. One advantage of low-cost index funds is not having to worry about the daily gyrations.

Sep 15πŸ‘ 0πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
Entertainment

Should the Kennedy Center be renamed after President Trump if that is what it takes to keep it from closing?

He's the reason they're in the current mess. That's only one of the many reasons he shouldn't be named on the building.

Sep 15πŸ‘ 0πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
News & Politics

Was the Pentagon wrong to press U.S. airmen shot down over Iran to appear in a '60 Minutes' interview?

The management shift at CBS News / 60 Minutes was definitely noticeable. I already miss Scott Pelley and Cecilia Vega.

Sep 15πŸ‘ 0πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
News & Politics

Should U.S. presidential candidates be required to have previously held public office?

Replying to Douglas_Gilligan: β€œOnly because of Trump, and at the point when this becomes law, he will be history. My understanding of the diagnostic process is that it pr…”

I'm reluctant to say "only because of Trump". He was elected twice -- and after a Trump-inspired insurrection. I'm not 100% confident we wouldn't make equally bad decisions in the future. The last 10 years have really undermined my confidence in our collective wisdom.

Sep 13πŸ‘ 1πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
Replying to Douglas_Gilligan: β€œAgreed. Most voters vote emotionally. It is through pain that they change. Upon Trump's second term, I knew it had to get worse before it…”

I do hope you're right. I hope there's a collective sigh of relief when the chaos recedes and we return to something more normal. My fear is that we align to a new normal.

Sep 15πŸ‘ 1πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
News & Politics

Should a sitting U.S. president be able to be criminally charged while still in office?

Replying to sjs: β€œWhere there isn't the political will in congress to impeach there should be a mechanism for states weigh in on serious offenses. And I'm so…”

No one is above the law. For the president, it requires strong safeguards against politically motivated prosecutions, but the principle holds.

Sep 15πŸ‘ 0πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
Entertainment

When watching a movie franchise, do you go in release order or chronological story order?

Replying to Moonshadow: β€œThe order the creators intend you to watch things in is the correct order to watch them in.”

Agreed. The sequencing is part of the filmmaker's vision. Best to see it as they intended.

Sep 15πŸ‘ 0πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
News & Politics

When do you think the war in Ukraine will end?

Replying to Moonshadow: β€œRussia can't afford to stand up against the entire rest of the world's economies combined much longer.”

I hope you're right. This war has gone on way too long. I'm worried there are too many side channels and Russian allies to make it unsustainable for Russia, though. They have the scale to maintain a war of attrition longer than Ukraine, so I fear it's going to take either pressure from China and N. Korea (don't see that happening) or stronger support from the US and NATO allies.

Sep 15πŸ‘ 0πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
Tech & Science

Was President Trump right to dismiss calls for stronger guardrails on artificial intelligence?

Trump says AI doesn’t need guardrails, only a β€˜high IQ’ president'. Can he please suggest one? Good grief.

Sep 15πŸ‘ 0πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
News & Politics

Should only Congress β€” not the president β€” have the power to send U.S. troops into combat?

There are times it's important that POTUS has the option, but with clear boundaries and time limits. Large scale and long-term commitments need the guardrails of Congress.

Sep 13πŸ‘ 0πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
Replying to JE_Thomas: β€œThe War Powers Act gives the president flexibility to react to emergent situations while demanding Congressional notification within 48 hour…”

Completely agree. Guardrails / checks and balances only work if there's the will to enforce them. It's disheartening how we've come up short on that front through the Trump era. I hope this is a phase we learn from as a country rather than precedents we normalize.

Sep 13πŸ‘ 1πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
Replying to sjs: β€œPersonally I'd like to see a constitutional amendment which prohibits and branch for delegating its authority or responsibility to another b…”

You’d think the separation of powers already covers this. Sadly, that doesn't seem to be the case with this Congress. I'm not sure what the Republican party stands for anymore.

Sep 14πŸ‘ 0πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
News & Politics

Should the U.S. president be required to hold a televised press conference at least once a month?

In this age of always-on media, I'm not sure that's necessary. I might feel differently, though, if we had a president who wasn't making shocking headlines daily.

Sep 14πŸ‘ 0πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
News & Politics

Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent says US can grow its way out of the debt crunch. You:

Even if we could, continuing to scale our debt with GDP is not a healthy strategy. We need to get our deficits under control so that debt as a % of GDP decreases as we grow. Enough with burdening future generations with our excesses.

Sep 14πŸ‘ 0πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
News & Politics

Should the U.S. spend more or less on foreign aid to other countries?

More than since the recent cuts. Foreign aid buys goodwill, influence, and stability at a pretty modest cost.

Sep 14πŸ‘ 0πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
News & Politics

Some experts estimate the chance of human extinction from AI in the next decade at over 10%. You think that:

When those inside the frontier AI companies are expressing this level of fear, we really need to take it seriously. We are in uncharted territory.

Sep 12πŸ‘ 0πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
Replying to JE_Thomas: β€œI didn't vote because I'm not privy to all of the relevant information. Besides, I think that H. sapiens has an excellent chance of annhili…”

That's very true. Maybe AI can help mitigate the risk that already existed before AI. Wouldn't it be ironic if AI ended up protected us from ourselves.

Sep 13πŸ‘ 0πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
News & Politics

In the U.S. war with Iran, should the U.S. focus on negotiating an end to the fighting or keep up military pressure?

Replying to JE_Thomas: β€œTrump claims, among many of his claims, that his war is about stopping Iran from getting a nuclear weapon. But Iran was already in complian…”

Love that. Well said. Can't wait for the mid-terms!

Sep 13πŸ‘ 0πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
Business & Money

Do you ever buy lottery tickets?

Replying to JE_Thomas: β€œLottery tickets are a stupidity tax. Now I'm waiting for someone to respond, " but somebody has to win!" A. No, they don't, and B. When s…”

I do agree. It's a tax that comes with a bit of offsetting entertainment value. If people only bought for that, I'd be okay with it. Unfortunately, it's often people who can't really afford them who are buying them.

Sep 13πŸ‘ 0πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
News & Politics

Should English be made the official language of the United States?

Depends on what the implications are of being an official language. I support English as the national standard, but not at the expense of practical accommodations for non-English speakers.

Sep 13πŸ‘ 0πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
Tech & Science

Should social media platforms require users to verify their real identity?

Really depends on the type of platform. If you want a platform where there's more accountability for what's said and behaviors more in line with how we engage in person, for sure. If you want behaviors not bound by societal norms, then no. I generally prefer the former, but to each his own.

Sep 13πŸ‘ 0πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
Business & Money

Should the U.S. replace the federal income tax with a national sales tax?

A tax only on consumption could certainly simplify the tax system and bring consistency to where/how we get taxed (not when earn or hold, but when we spend), but we'd need other mechanisms to offset for lower income earners (maybe exemptions or rebates to a certain amount).

Sep 13πŸ‘ 0πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
Replying to JE_Thomas: β€œSales taxes are regressive. Replacing income tax with a national sales tax would only exacerbate wealth inequalities and lead to a two clas…”

They're regressive on their own, yes. There are ways to address that, though (exemptions, rebates, credits). If implemented with such measures, a national sales tax can actually be more progressive, ensuring that the wealthy pay their fair share (if/when they want to enjoy their money -- i.e. spend it -- there's no way to avoid the tax).

Sep 13πŸ‘ 0πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
Just for Fun

Would you drink the leftover juice straight from a pickle jar?

Do people do this?

Sep 13πŸ‘ 0πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
Entertainment

Should celebrities keep their political opinions to themselves?

Free speech.

Sep 13πŸ‘ 1πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
News & Politics

Should the U.S. Vice President be elected separately from the President rather than chosen as a running mate?

Replying to JE Thomas: β€œRunning president and vice president as a team just underscores partisanship. In the earliest days of the republic the vice president was t…”

I agree that partisanship has gotten out of control. Working across the isle seems to be a lost art. As far as the VP decision, though, my hesitation in that taking it out of the hands of the president risks pushing partisanship inside the executive branch, only making matters worse.

Sep 13πŸ‘ 1πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
Replying to anonymous: β€œThe White House? No. The vice presidency is at best a ceremonial position unless the president chooses to give that person something to do…”

True, but as the president's immediate successor and a tie-breaking vote in the Senate, it's best that they're somewhat aligned.

Sep 13πŸ‘ 0πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
Business & Money

Would you take part of your paycheck in cryptocurrency if your employer offered it?

Replying to Douglas_Gilligan: β€œSInce ~90% of what we do with banks these day, can be done online or at an ATM, why not an online bank account for each person, that is free…”

Yes, would love to find a way to avoid the 2-3% fees on credit card transactions, not to mention the other bank fees. Crypto can play a role here, but needs some type of national or major institutional backing.

Sep 12πŸ‘ 0πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’
Just for Fun

Which breakfast meat is better β€” bacon or sausage?

Replying to rovr322: β€œBlack pudding!”

Sorry, I mentally can't do black pudding.

Sep 12πŸ‘ 0πŸ‘Ž 0Open thread β†’

Founding Voices β†’

dagman β€” Groundbeat