Should Ukraine give up the Donbas region to Russia in exchange for NATO membership?
President Volodymyr Zelensky said U.S. envoys asked whether Ukraine would cede the eastern Donbas to Russia in exchange for NATO membership, adding he would put any formal offer to the public.
This sounds like the U.S./Britain back in Willy Loman-mode again, believing it's still in a position to dictate terms. Russia has already taken the Donbass, to local jubilation. It has also demanded Ukraine remain a buffer to NATO expansion rather than another domino, a stance they have been consistent for decades. Hence, what both parts of this "deal" represent is a move to the "Bargaining" stage of grief for this whole travesty.
Russia invaded a sovereign country. It should not benefit from its aggression.
These talking-points are colossal and demonstrable lies of omission. The Donbass was packaged into Ukraine by something akin to accident. After the US-sponsored Maidan coup in 2014, it became a target of ethnic cleansing by the openly neo-NAZI (aka "Banderite") junta which Zelensky initially ran to clean up/kick out, but wound up becoming a hostage to instead. They were promised a referendum on whether they wanted to secede to Russia long ago, but it was broken. All that, AND Russia's clear and consistent insistence ever since the fall of the USSR that Ukraine was their "red line", was why it invaded. The legality of the invasion may be gray, but the Cuban Missile Crisis was peanuts next to what NATO's been doing in everyone else's backyard. As JFK said, we cannot negotiate with those who say "what's mine is mine and what's yours is negotiable"; the Russians merely called bullshit on a rigged system.
The Donbas was folded into Ukraine after the 1918 revolution. Poland, Latvia, Estonia, and Lithuania were all once part of Greater Russia. Of course Texas and California once belonged to Mexico. Russia doesn't get to call bullshit on anyone. Russia, a vast nation of 140-ish million spanning 11 time zones has a GDP about the size of Italy's. Despite producing some of the world's most brilliant mathematicians, physicists, writers and composers, Russia can't build a toaster that anyone - including most Russians - wants to buy. Theirs is extractive economy like Oman and Namibia. They maintain an illusion of importance by threatening their neighbors rather than transforming Russia into a truly great nation; they have all the necessities to do it. But that isn't how oligarchic autocracies work. I'm not sure what you're referring to regarding NATO and "everyone's" backyard. NATO has been relatively moribund since the collapse of the Soviet Union until ... cut me off
if you're voting "only if Ukrainians approve it in a vote" - approved by whom, people still living in Donbas or the whole country, and does that change your answer?