A quiet week for consensus, a loud one for refusal: Groundbeat voters drew a tip-percentage line, declined most new technology in their homes and vacations, and still landed firmly on one side of the airplane recline question.
❓ The open question: Political robocalls and texts
Election Day was Tuesday, so the campaign texts should ease off for a while. The Do Not Call list was never going to stop them, since the FTC's rules allow political calls, along with charities, debt collectors and surveys (FTC).
So we asked: should political robocalls and texts be banned?
The cases
Dense1 doubts any rule would hold: "Hard to imagine a way to stop this in a world based on advertising"
JE_Thomas wants candidates treated like any other caller: "You can block robot-calls from commercial interests but not from political candidates? Why not? I get gimme requests from candidates as far away as Texas, Maine, and Ohio. I don't live in those states. Block 'em!"
dagman, a week before the vote, was counting on a quieter November: "Getting a flurry of political texts now. Looking forward to Nov 4 when spam texts will subside, I'm sure."
Scaramouche wasn't so sure: "Surely you jest; that's when they'll start talking about 2028!"
What the desk adds
The rule that does apply turns on how a text is sent. Under federal law, a campaign text to a cell phone sent by an autodialer needs your prior consent, and one sent manually doesn't (FCC).
Home landlines get less protection. A campaign can robocall one without consent, up to three times in any 30 days. Where consent was required, replying "stop" has to be honored, and forwarding an unwanted text to 7726 reports the sender (same FCC guide).
Next week's open question
What was the biggest reason Republicans lost control of Congress in the midterms? So far the thread splits on how much of it comes down to Trump himself, and two members on opposite sides have agreed to sort it out over a few beers.
The 19-21% tip settles in
A clear majority of voters put their average sit-down tip at 19-21% (55%), with the extremes on either end staying thin — only 4% land at 25% or more. See the live results →
107 votes · 5 from members
Nobody wants an AI travel agent
82% of voters said they wouldn't let an AI plan their entire vacation itinerary, and even the softened option — final approval reserved — only drew 11%. See the live results →
55 votes · 8 from members
Recline away
A majority (54%) said reclining your airplane seat is fine, while 25% called it rude and the remaining 21% made it conditional on flight length. See the live results →
63 votes · 9 from members
Four days, most of the time
76% of voters backed a four-day workweek for most companies; the 'only some industries' middle ground barely registered at 3%. See the live results →
33 votes · 7 from members
Streaming's cost-benefit case slips
76% of voters said streaming services aren't worth the money anymore as prices climb, against just 10% who still find the value. See the live results →
29 votes · 5 from members
💬 From the discussions
A thread on what drove Republicans' midterm losses, with voters split on who owns the chaos.
“Plenty to criticize on both sides. But at this point in time, most of the angst stems from Trump's actions and style.” — dagman
“Still disagree……looks like we’ll have to get together over a few beers and sort this one out….or maybe just drink some beers!” — rovr322
A thread on tying federal disaster aid to election results, with a counterexample raised and then addressed.
“I seem to recall Biden’s FEMA being instructed not to assist people in N Carolina that had Trump banners outside their houses after they had massive flooding a few years ago” — rovr322
🗣 The Minority Report
“Only if a reasonable expectation of ridership would justify the cost (considering also its impact on congestion and environment). In California, I'm concerned that both ridership expectations and cost estimates are overly optimistic.”
— dagman, making the case for the trailing side. A trailing option defended with specifics rather than slogans, which is rarer than it should be. Join that thread →
Polls stay open, so add your take if any of these are missing a side.
Help us build this. We're building the Groundbeat community one person at a time, and we need your help — if you know someone who belongs here, please send them groundbeat.com.